The comments that are coming in are quite revealing! Opinion is very divided, and more than one of the four finalist gowns is causing controversy. I’ve summarised some of the best comments on the finalists page at YWU.
Meanwhile, I’ll give you my own take (and I’ll try to be impartial – I have my favourites too!) What are the possibilities and the pitfalls in each of our finalist patterns?
1780-90 Sacque gown
Compared to many 18th century gowns, this one is quite simple. Looking closely at the photograph and the pattern, you’ll notice that the sacque back is not “built in” at the back section of the gown, but is a separate drape attached at the back neck (there’s daylight between the mannequin’s back and the drape.) You could say that this doesn’t make it a “real” sacque gown, however.
The pattern includes the gown only, but of course we’ll offer some possibilities for adding underskirt, stays and so on if you would like to. Meanwhile, by shortening the skirt there are possibilities to simplify the gown into a short jacket of the type worn in period.
Overall, not a classic sacque back shape, but a relatively simple introduction to the eighteenth century look, with lots of possibilities for the ambitious.
1885 Summer Dress
If you’re looking for a pattern that’ll really test us as we write your tutorials, and give you value for your subscription, this is it. In the 1880s the Victorian quest for perfect fitting methods reached its height of bizarre complexity as they wrestled with this cuirasse bodice, closely fitted right through from neck to hip.
Meanwhile, there’s lots of draping fun to be had with the seemingly complex arrangement of layers and ruffles in the skirt, plus bustle goodness a-plenty.
For the less confident, I’d suggest playing with one half or the other of this gown, either working on fitting a bodice (I can’t help picturing it with jeans or a plain skirt) or looking into the skirt draping and modernising that arrangement of layers and ruffles to make something that’s wearable today.
Overall, this is a complex fitting challenge, but it’s also a project to really get your teeth into.
1860s Day Dress
For number of garments, you can’t beat this mix-and-match fiesta. You have skirt, day bodice, bolero jacket and an alternative evening bodice (not illustrated) – but don’t forget that you can make as many or as few elements of the pattern as you wish.
There are many possibilities for using this gown as your blank slate for embellishments, as well as for leaving it plain and concentrating on cut and fit. Again, underpinning guidance will be there in the tutorials, although all the underpinnings won’t be necessary if you think laterally enough or modernise.
Overall, a pattern with many pieces that will perhaps be overwhelming for some to pick their way through at first, but also a pattern with many, many options that can offer possibilities for everyone.
1797 Empire Gown
This seemingly inocuous gown, more than any of the other finalists, has caused the most controversy. Some of you love it, pointing to its apparent simplicity, the lack of fabric in comparison to the others, and the lack of need for underpinnings.
(That’s true – the 1797 fashionista supposedly wore no corset with her gown, but the average woman most certainly still did, leaving you with plenty of equally valid underpinning options in period.)
On the other hand, some of you dislike it intensely, fearing that it’ll make you look dumpy or that the possibilities for adapting or varying it are limited. But, as GinaB puts it, “perhaps that’s the point, we should be thinking how we can make it better, using the basic pattern?”
Overall, perhaps a simple option (or is it? Look at the pattern and see what you think), but a more difficult gown to vary.
***
Have you decided what to vote for yet? Remember, you’ve only got one vote this time. The poll opens on Friday at midday GMT as before, and runs for 24 hours. I’ll email you with a reminder. Feel free to email us with your vote now if you won’t be around during that time.
In the meantime, did you start out rooting for one gown, but have changed your mind now? What made you shift your vote?